For new and experienced dog owners alike, one question, in particular, seems to plague our minds – should we get a dog harness or collar? Popping back to the forefront whenever we’re walking our dogs, we wonder if they’re comfortable. Can they breathe easily? Or are they tugging too much?

This all stems back to whether we think they should wear a collar or harness. Well, the choice is up to you and what suits your dog best. However, sometimes this is easier said than done, and we all want reassurance and guidance on whether we’re doing the right thing for our animals. 

To help you with your decision-making, you can find all of the benefits of collars and harnesses right here! 

This is a guest article aimed at providing useful information to readers.

The Benefits of a Harness

Let’s begin with harnesses, which have been popular for everyday wear more recently than the dog collar. Originally, harnesses were used for dogs pulling weights, like huskies pulling sledges in the snow. But now they are widely used to take dogs on everyday strolls. Here’s why. 


Provide More Control 

A lot of dog owners who swear by harnesses usually do so as they believe using a harness offers more control over the dog. This is true, as a harness has a much larger surface area which covers the dog’s chest, shoulders and upper back. This area on your dog is their strongest point, which means having better control to reign your dog without damaging its neck. 

For this reason, harnesses are typically better for those with an out-of-control or more excitable dog who likes to pull or a dog much larger or stronger than their owner. 

Relieve Pressure on your Dog

Like the above, a harness can relieve the pressure on your dog’s neck as it pulls on its lead. This is not just an issue for over-excitable dogs hoping to run ahead but for slower dogs that may even just want to stop and smell the flowers. Literally! 

Because harnesses sit a little bit lower down on your dog’s trachea area, they are the perfect option for dogs with neck problems. Not forgetting dog breeds with flat faces who may already find breathing difficult. 

Added Security 

When trying to guide your dog in the right direction, a harness provides better guidance as it is secured to your dog in multiple positions. Rather than just pulling and leading by their neck, a harness wraps around the chest, front legs, and back, leaving less wiggle room for your dog to plan a deviant route. 

Plus, with a high-quality adjustable harness, you can create the perfect fit for your dog to ensure total comfort and security during their walk for both pet and owner. 

The Benefits of a Collar 

So, now we have listed the benefits of a harness; it is only fair we do the same with collars to give you an accurate comparison. The collar is a classic part of a dog’s wardrobe and won’t disappear anytime soon. Many dog owners still love using a collar for their pooch, here’s why. 

Dog harness or Collar  which is best benji the westie

Lightweight and Comfortable 

It might seem obvious, but collars are lightweight and designed to fit your dog’s neck perfectly, with many quality, adjustable collars available. They are especially useful in warmer weather, like how humans prefer to swap their jeans for shorts! 

A collar also tends to have more movement than a harness, so if your dog walks well on their lead, you can afford to give them that little bit more wiggle room and comfort. 

Because collars are significantly lighter and easier to wear, many pet owners tend to feel more comfortable leaving their pup’s collar on for longer periods of time. For example, when off-lead at a friend’s house or dog play centre. It means they are still easily identifiable from afar without having to keep a full harness on. 

More Convenient 

We must remember how convenient a dog collar is, as the design is simple yet efficient. It’s a universally understood mechanism. This means no matter who might be looking after your pooch, whether it’s family, the kennel club or a dog walker, they can simply and easily put on your dog’s collar. 

Plus, collars are arguably easier to put on than harnesses, making them an ideal choice for dogs that can’t stop wiggling when they know they’re about to go on a walk. Unlike harnesses, which require much more calm to put on and fasten securely. 

Designed for ID Tags

As dog collars have been around longer and are more popular than harnesses, their design specifically has been adapted for ID tags. All collars are equipped with a small metal hoop to attach ID tags. Finding identification and owner details is easy for anyone who may spot your pooch when they have gone walkabout. 

Dog harness or collar which is best

Which Should You Choose?

So, which should you choose? It is clear that both collars and harnesses have their benefits, so it is up to you to decide which points you value more for your dog. 

Are they too strong to handle on a lead? Then you might want to choose a harness. 

Or maybe they spend a lot of time outside of your home; then, you may be better off with a collar. 

There are a lot of considerations for you to make, and we hope we have helped you with the harness vs collar debate.

benefits of getting a dog for your child
The benefits of getting a dog for your family.
dog-friendly east yorkshire
A Dog-friendly weekend in East Yorkshire.